Coenzyme Q10 or CoQ10 is an organic molecule that is naturally synthesized in
the liver. According to Dr. Karl Folkers and other experts, humans can
biosynthesize coenzyme Q10 from tyrosine through a cascade of aromatic
precursors which indispensably require certain vitamins: vitamins B2, B6, B12,
folic acid, niacin, and pantothenic acid. CoQ10 is comprised of a quinone ring
and a hydrocarbon side chain made up of 10 isoprene units. This side chain is
synthesized from acetyl-CoA. The quinone ring is synthesized from the amino
acids (tyrosine or phenylalanine) and is responsible for CoQ10 having such
powerful antioxidant activity. The reduced form of CoQ10 is able to scavenge
free radicals that may cause damage to the body’s DNA, proteins, and lipids,
opening the door to a host of various diseases including cardiovascular disease,
and neurodegerative diseases such as Alzheimer’s or Parkinson’s.
Chemical Structure of Coenzyme Q10
Because it is a vitamin-like substance located in virtually every cell, CoQ10
is also known as ubiquinone—from “ubiquitous” to signify its widespread
distribution in the human body, and “quinone,” a chemical structure with a
unique ability to be oxidized and reduced. Found in most living organisms, it is
essential to the production of cellular energy and can be both synthesized in
the body and derived from dietary sources. There are dietary sources of CoQ10,
including meat, poultry and fish, but these sources contain a small amount of
CoQ10. Daily intakes from food typically range between 3 to 5 mg/day, which
cannot significantly raise blood and tissue levels.
Healthy humans who consume a well-balanced diet have the ability to
synthesize coenzyme Q10. Unhealthy individuals and those on an inadequate diet
may not synthesize CoQ10 in sufficient quantities. Thus, the biosynthesis of
coenzyme Q10 in the human body requires a good diet—one that is high in
vitamins, minerals, and other nutrient factors. The NHANES studies reveal that
many Americans do not have an adequate diet. Rather, their intake of most
water-soluble vitamins (B-complex vitamins and vitamin C), vitamin A and some
minerals and trace elements is insufficient. As noted earlier, many of these
nutrients are essential for the biosynthesis of coenzyme Q10. In addition, it
has been shown that in disease states, nutrients from food sources may not
necessarily be absorbed or available. According to some experts, coenzyme Q10
should be considered an essential nutrient, as it is well established that
coenzyme Q10 is essential for the health of every cell in the human body.
Coenzyme Q10 resembles vitamin K in its chemical structure. Biochemically,
reduced CoQ10 functions much like vitamin E in that it acts as an antioxidant by
donating a hydrogen to free radicals. Like vitamins E and K, CoQ10 is also a
lipophilic (fat-soluble) molecule. To better explain, it can only be absorbed in
the presence of fat, because it is water insoluble. For better CoQ10 absorption,
it either has to be introduced in a fat soluble medium or taken with fat in the
diet. Many question why CoQ10 should be supplemented, especially since we
produce it naturally in the body and obtain it in our food supply. It has been
suggested by some clinical data that the body’s natural ability to synthesize
CoQ10 may diminish as we age. In addition, those with heart disease seem to
produce even less, and they are the ones that need it the most.
Benefits
The most important role CoQ10 plays in the body is to support the production
and function of adenosine triphosphate, or ATP, the metabolic energy on which
the body runs. CoQ10 is found primarily within the membrane of a cell organelle
called the mitochondrion, which is often referred to as the “power house” of the
cell. Mitochondria are affectionately known as this because of their ability to
drive the production of ATP. CoQ10 is an important rate-limiting nutrient that
is a cofactor in the mitochondrial electron transport chain—the biochemical
pathway in cellular respiration from which ATP is derived. It serves as an
electron transport carrier during the processes of respiration and oxidative
phosphorylation. Since nearly all cellular activities are dependent upon energy,
coenzyme Q10 is essential for the health of all human tissues and organs.
The heart is one of the most metabolically active tissues in the body, thus
it requires large amounts of uninterrupted energy. Heart muscle cells have the
greatest concentration of mitochondria, and subsequently, more CoQ10 than any
other type of cell. Each heart cell can have thousands of mitochondria (5,000
per cell) to meet these energy demands.
Numerous studies indicate coenzyme Q10 also plays an important role in the
maintenance of the entire cardiovascular system. As previously mentioned, CoQ10,
in its reduced form, plays an important role as an antioxidant nutrient. The
antioxidant potential of CoQ10 helps our bodies prevent or delay cellular
deterioration. It is this deterioration that is one of the predominant causes of
heart disease. CoQ10 is essential for healthy heart function, as well as to
protect the veins and arteries from free radical damage. Research has shown that
CoQ10 supplementation exerts a sparing effect on vitamin E in healthy subjects.
It also reduces levels of lipid peroxidation, the pivotal step in the cause of
atherosclerosis, thereby decreasing the risk of cardiovascular diseases.
Several clinical trials have provided evidence supporting the use of
supplementation with CoQ10 in the prevention and treatment of various disorders
related to oxidative stress. It has been shown that CoQ10’s antioxidant
properties and its central role in mitochondrial oxidative phosphorylation make
it useful as adjunct therapy for cardiovascular diseases such as congestive
heart failure (a disease in which the heart does not adequately maintain
circulation), hypertension (high blood pressure), cardiomyopathy (heart muscle
disease), angina pectoris (chest pain), drug-induced cardiotoxicity, and
ventricular arrhythmia. A significant deficiency of CoQ10 was detected in
patients with hypertension. A pilot study showed that CoQ10 supplementation at
dosages that ranged from 30 to 360 mg/day to patients with hypertension led to
an increase in CoQ10 levels and statistically significant decreases in systolic
and diastolic blood pressure.
CoQ10 is also gaining notoriety as a helpful dietary supplement for
non-cardiac conditions including diabetes, Parkinson’s disease, periodontal
disease, compromised immune systems, cancer, muscular dystrophy, and chronic
obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD). There is substantial evidence that
oxidative damage may play a key role in the pathogenesis of neurodegenerative
diseases, such as Alzheimer’s and Parkinson’s diseases. In a recent study, the
percent content of the oxidized form of CoQ10 (a marker of oxidative stress) in
total CoQ10 (both oxidized and reduced forms) was found to be slightly elevated
in Parkinson’s disease patients, when compared with normal subjects, suggesting
elevated oxidative stress in Parkinson’s disease patients.
CoQ10 supports a broad range of functions in the body leading many experts to
suggest that CoQ10 should be an integral part of any dietary supplementation
program.
Effects of Statin Drugs on CoQ10
Cholesterol biosynthesis is a complex metabolic process. At least 26 steps
are involved in its production, and it shares a common pathway with CoQ10
synthesis. It is produced from acetyl-CoA, just like the isoprenoid side chain
of CoQ10. Hydroxymethylglutaryl-coenzyme A (HMG-CoA) is one of the next
substrates down the synthesis chain, requiring the enzyme HMG-CoA reductase to
form the mevalonate compound.
In the United States, millions of Americans are taking cholesterol-lowering
prescription drugs known as “statins” (Pravachol®, Zocor®, Lipitor®, etc.).
Statins are a class of pharmaceuticals that are used to lower cholesterol
levels, primarily LDL cholesterol. They are sometimes referred to as “HMG-CoA
reductase inhibitors,” because they block this key enzyme, which is responsible
for the body’s production of cholesterol. Essentially, it inhibits the
endogenous production of cholesterol.
Inhibition of HMG-CoA reductase by statin drugs at the mevalonate level will
inevitably decrease the levels of both cholesterol and CoQ10. The
cholesterol-lowering medications interfere with the body’s ability to produce
CoQ10, because these drugs also block the manufacture of other substances
necessary for body functions including CoQ10. Ironically, the drugs are taken to
lower cholesterol, but at the same time CoQ10, which protects the heart, is
produced on a much smaller scale. People taking statin drugs can develop CoQ10
deficiencies and may require supplementation. Several studies revealed a
possible dose-related and significant decrease in CoQ10 serum levels as a result
of HMG-CoA reductase inhibitor treatment (e.g., simvastatin, pravastatin,
lovastatin) alone. In a double-blind, randomized clinical trial
hypercholesterolemic patients received either lovastatin or pravastatin over a
period of 18 weeks. At the end of the study period, the total serum level of
CoQ10 declined by about 25 percent in the lovastatin and pravastatin groups.
Supplementing with CoQ10 is necessary to prevent its depletion in the body
while on these drugs. Furthermore, the LDL cholesterol that is limited by statin
drugs is one of the primary transport compounds for CoQ10 in humans. Clearly,
statins deliver a double-threat to CoQ10 status through their limitation of
production and transport of this important cofactor.
Simplified Cholesterol and Coenzyme Q10 Synthesis Diagram
Supplementation and Safety
CoQ10’s safety has been evaluated. Doses of 30-60 mg/day are generally
recommended to prevent CoQ10 deficiency and to maintain normal serum
concentrations of 0.7-1.0 µg/mL (micrograms per milliliter). However,
therapeutic doses of 100-200 mg/day are advocated for the treatment of chronic
heart disease. These higher doses may achieve serum concentrations of 2.0-3.0
µg/mL, reported by some investigators to have a positive impact on
cardiovascular health. The dosage in a Parkinson’s disease study ranged from
300-1200 mg/day, taken for 16 months. The group that received the largest dose
of CoQ10 (1200 mg/day) displayed less of a decline in mental function, motor
function, and ability to carry out activities of daily living.
If CoQ10 is going to be effective, adequate blood levels must be maintained
for a prolonged period.
CoQ10 is absorbed slowly. Absorption is dependent on the presence of fat in
the gastrointestinal (g.i.) tract. Peak plasma levels are attained within 5-10
hours following oral administration. CoQ10 is primarily excreted through the
biliary tract, and over 60% of the oral dose is recovered in the feces.
With this very basic understanding of CoQ10, you’ll now be able to appreciate
the superiority of CoQsol-CF™.
Commercial Production of CoQ10 Supplements
There are currently two different manufacturing techniques being used to
commercially produce coenzyme Q10. Soft Gel Technologies, Inc.® has access to
material from three different Japanese manufacturers. One manufacturer, Nisshin
Pharma, uses the solanesol method and the other two manufacturers, Kaneka and
Asahi, use the microbiological fermentation method. The following is a brief
summary of the two manufacturing methods:
The Solanesol Method:
The first CoQ10 to be admitted as a pharmaceutical ingredient in Japan was
produced by the solanesol method. Plants from the Solanaceae family
contain a nine-isoprenoid long alcohol known as solanesol. Solanesol is first
extracted from the plant and is then converted to a ten-isoprenoid compound
called decaprenol. During the final step, the decaprenol is reacted with
hydroquninone to produce CoQ10. The CoQ10 produced by the solanesol method has a
long history of safety and efficacy. The compound actually extracted from the
tobacco leaf is the solanesol. The process begins with a n-hexane extraction.
The solvent is removed by molecular distillation.
With this method, both trans and cis forms of CoQ10 are formed but subsequent
purification steps reduce the quantity of cis isomers to below 0.5%, generally
below 0.2%. Nisshin Pharma’s specification is not more than 0.5%.
Microbiological Fermentation:
Coenzyme Q10 produced by microbiological fermentation was also admitted as a
pharmaceutical ingredient in Japan and also has a long history of safety and
efficacy. With the fermentation method, selected strains of microbes are placed
in a fortified molasses-based carbohydrate medium where they produce CoQ10, as
well as CoQ6, CoQ7, CoQ9 and CoQ11 during the fermentation process. The actual
microbe used in the process is proprietary. The carbohydrate medium used is
derived from sugar beets, but its exact composition is also proprietary.
Subsequent purification steps generally greatly reduce or eliminate the
presence of other coenzyme homologues listed above. The USP specification for
non-CoQ10 homologues is 1.0%. All of our material meets this requirement.
Material produced in this manner is considered natural in the United States,
Europe and Japan. The CoQ10 used is produced by microbiological fermentation,
which is the all-trans isomer form.
Recently, there has been a great deal of controversy regarding differences in
isomer (cis vs. trans) impurities contained commercially-available products. It
is important to note that the compounds involved in the controversy are not
hazardous. These impurities are compounds having positive health benefits but
the health benefits are not as great as the benefits obtained from all-trans
coenzyme Q10.
Coenzyme Q10 manufactured using the solanesol method has the potential to
contain “cis” isomers in which the ten-isoprenoid unit tail is bent rather than
straight. It is commonly believed that the bent tail limits the molecule’s
ability to penetrate cellular and organelle membranes. It is also possible that
material made using the solanesol method contains some CoQ9. Subsequent
purification steps generally greatly reduce or nearly eliminate the presence of
these isomers.
Coenzyme Q10 manufactured by microbiological fermentation is 100% in the
all-trans isomeric form, identical in structure of the coenzyme Q10 made by the
human body. However, material made by microbiological fermentation has the
potential to contain other homologues, sometimes referred to “related
substances” such as CoQ7, CoQ8, and/or CoQ9. Subsequent purification steps
generally greatly reduce or eliminate the presence of the other forms of
coenzymes listed above.
All the coenzyme Q10 material utilized by Soft Gel Technologies, Inc.® is
guaranteed to be a minimum of 98% pure. This is considered a natural material
and is in full compliance with the current United States Pharmacopeia/ National
Formulary (USP/NF), European Pharmacopeia, and Japanese Pharmacopeia monographs
and standards.
CoQ10 Raw Material Availability
CoQ10 is a raw material and finished good that is important to our customers
and is in short supply this year. Most people are aware that the availability of
CoQ10 continues to be very scarce. Four factors contribute to this type of
market condition. The first factor is attributed to an increased demand for
CoQ10 when it was granted FOSHU (Foods for Specific Health Use) status in Japan.
The second factor was the publication of research supporting higher dosages for
therapeutic applications. Third, the planned expansion of production facilities
and necessary closures during the construction process created a shortage of raw
material. The fourth factor surfaced unexpectedly, because manufacturing
difficulties lead to unplanned closure of facilities. These factors follow the
basic supply and demand economic model, thereby driving prices up to record
levels.
When raw material is scarce, the primary impact of the shortage is increased
pricing. The market tends to ration material to those who exhibit the greatest
demand. Secondary impacts include a slowed rate of product development and
product introductions. Manufacturers will only introduce a new product if they
feel strongly assured that their vendor can consistently maintain a supply of
the necessary ingredients. Shortages can undermine confidence throughout the
supply chain—from the end consumer to their retailer, and continues up through
the manufacturer and their supplier.
At Soft Gel Technologies, Inc.®, we have leveraged our long term
relationships with our suppliers and our capital in order to secure an adequate
supply of key ingredients. We are still subject to market fluctuations, but we
feel that this is preferable as opposed to not having material for our
customers. Manufacturers that have cultivated relationships with suppliers tend
to do well in a volatile market. On the other hand, companies that are
opportunistic in their purchasing strategy and forego developing an alliance
with vendors are more susceptible to the ebb and flow of the marketplace.
Finished product manufacturers can apply innovative strategies with key
ingredients that are subject to scarcity, by capitalizing on synergistic
combinations of ingredients or by utilizing delivery systems that enhance
bioavailability. Soft Gel Technologies, Inc.® encompasses this methodology in
its efforts to cope with a fluctuating market. As a result of research and
development efforts, we have developed a CoQ10 product that is 100% solubilized.
This formulation provides our customers with a high level of value and excellent
results regarding CoQ10 bioavailability. This new product is called CoQsol-CF™,
the “crystal-free” advantage.
CoQsol-CF™
CoQsol-CF™ is a unique, patent-pending formula comprised of CoQ10,
d-limonene, tocopherols (vitamin E), and medium chain triglycerides (MCTs). This
combination created a liquid (100% solubilized), crystal-free solution of CoQ10
that provides enhanced bioavailability. It contains all natural ingredients.
Even the gelatin shell color is derived from turmeric. No synthetic dyes are
utilized.
d-Limonene
To fully understand the characteristics of this non-polar, organic solvent,
some background information regarding volatile oils is provided below.
Volatile Oils
Volatile oils, also known as essential oils, are complex chemical substances,
frequently having two or three hundred constituents. Most volatile oils are
carbon-hydrogen compounds (hydrocarbons), and terpenes are the most common
hydrocarbons. They are responsible for providing the scent to various parts of a
plant. When exposed to air or steam, they evaporate, which explains why they are
called “volatile” oils. In citrus fruits (orange, lemon, lime, etc.), these oils
can be found in oil reservoirs from the fruit peel.
Methods of extraction for volatile oils vary, but most are extracted by
distillation. Water distillation is used for the more robust oils, particularly
those high in terpenes. Water and steam distillation is the method most commonly
used, being powerful yet gentle for more sensitive constituents. The volatile
oils thus distilled float on the surface of the distillate and can be separated
easily. Direct steam distillation may be used where the plant is prepared very
soon after picking.
Biochemistry of Volatile Oils
Plants have the capacity to synthesize low molecular weight compounds that
are called secondary metabolites, because their role in growth and development
is unclear. The largest class of secondary metabolites in plants is the
terpenoids (or terpenes). The structure of terpenes varies widely, as they can
exhibit hundreds of different carbon skeletons. However, they do share a common
feature: all terpenes have carbon atom isoprene units in multiples of 5.
Terpenes are formed from acetyl-CoA via the mevalonic acid pathway, since
mevalonic acid and isopentenyl pyrophosphate are involved in their biosynthesis.
The properties of a volatile oil are determined by the number of isoprene
units and the various side groups (such as alcohols, esters, acids, nitrogen,
and sulphur) that may be attached. If a terpene has no added side groups, it is
called an unoxygenated terpene. The most common type of terpenes in volatile
oils are monoterpenes—hydrocarbons consisting of two isoprene units. Limonene
found in more than 30 species of fruits and vegetables, especially in citrus
oils, is a specific monoterpene hydrocarbon that exists naturally as the
dextrorotatory isomer, d-limonene.
d-Limonene
There are several applications for d-limonene in the food and pharmaceutical
industries. The Food and Drug Administration recognized d-limonene to be
Generally Recognized As Safe (GRAS) in 1960 as a synthetic flavoring substance.
In 1965 a Flavor and Extract Manufacturers’ Association (FEMA) expert panel
determined d-limonene to be GRAS. It is widely used as a flavor additive in
foods and beverages, as a fragrance in perfumes and a variety of household
products, and as an industrial solvent and degreaser. Recently, d-limonene has
become a potential candidate for a variety of medical applications because of
its reported use as a chemoprotective agent in experimental animal models.
Several dietary supplements have been introduced to the natural products
industry that contain food-grade d-limonene with potencies up to 1000 mg per
serving to address a variety of health concerns. There are two main grades of
d-limonene obtained as a by-product of the citrus juice industry—food grade and
technical grade. Food-grade d-limonene undergoes a distillation process, and is
used for consumer products, while technical grade d-limonene is used for
industrial products.
This monoterpene solvent was chosen to be in CoQsol-CF™ for its solubilizing
properties. CoQ10, with its side chain of isoprenoid units, is highly soluble in
hydrocarbon monoterpenes, including d-limonene (“Like dissolves like” chemistry
principle). d-Limonene can be combined with CoQ10 without causing chemical
interactions or degradation.
Like Dissolves Like
When two or more
substances are mixed together in solution, solubility must be
considered. Simply defined, solubility is a measure of how much solute
will dissolve into the solvent. Not all substances will dissolve in all
solvents. Understanding solubility properties will provide a basis for
understanding the golden rule of solubility...Like dissolves like.
Temperature, molecular size, and polarity all affect
solubility. When solvent and solute molecules are structurally similar, the
solute will dissolve in the solvent. For example, non-polar compounds dissolve
non-polar compounds and the more similar the polarities of 2 different
compounds, the more soluble they should be.
Vitamin E Tocopherols
Tocopherols are added because they enhance the biological function of CoQ10,
which in turn, helps maintain the antioxidant state of vitamin E. Vitamin E is
important to the action of CoQ10, because it is used to convert CoQ10 to its
most active reduced form. CoQ10 can work synergistically with vitamin E,
regenerating its active form, tocopherol, in the same synergistic mechanism as
with vitamin C. Preparations of CoQ10 that contain lipid vehicles, such as
vitamin E, increase solubility and yield more efficient absorption rates than
that of the purified coenzyme alone.
During supplementation with CoQ10, the level of lipid peroxidation decreased
in healthy subjects, yet levels of another antioxidant, vitamin E, remained
constant. It appears CoQ10 exerts a sparing effect on vitamin E and perhaps more
efficiently prevents lipid peroxidation (by inhibiting both its initiation and
propagation, whereas vitamin E inhibits only propagation).
Biochemistry of CoQ10
CoQ10 is made up of a quinone ring, but also contains a side chain consisting
of ten repeating 5-carbon isoprene units. Because of its structure, CoQ10 is
highly lipophilic and practically insoluble in water. This lipophilic nature
also affects bioavailability, making its absorption poor, highly variable, and
strongly dependent on the stomach’s contents (i.e. foods rich in fat). Another
major factor in the bioavailability of CoQ10 is the large size of the molecule.
Dietary supplement encapsulators try to develop delivery systems for CoQ10 to
enhance bioavailability, and have utilized oil-based soft gel capsules
containing microemulsions rather than powder-based forms of this nutrient.
However, most CoQ10 dosage forms exhibit negligible dissolution—no more than
10%.
It is clear that the dosage form of a supplement has a significant effect on
nutrient bioavailability. Absorption into the general circulation is an
important part of delivery. In general, the effect of dosage form on
bioavailability depends on the rapidity with which the particular form releases
the nutrient into the biological fluids or how rapidly the nutrient may permeate
a cell membrane. Not surprisingly, absorption is most rapid from solutions and
decreases in the order: solutions, suspensions, capsules, compressed tablets,
coated tablets. Commercially available CoQ10 dosage forms include powder-based
tablets (compressed), powder-filled capsules (2-piece hard shell), and soft
gelatin capsules. Other forms, such as chewable wafers, intra-oral sprays, and
intravenous solutions, are available, but are less common.
As previously discussed, the dosage form of a supplement has a significant
effect on bioavailability. A prerequisite to absorption is dissolution, and this
is a disadvantage of the powder-forms of CoQ10. Better preparations appear to be
soft gel capsules with CoQ10 in an oil base, but absorption is still dependent
upon the number and size of CoQ10 crystals in the product.
Crystals
Crystals are formed when CoQ10 is produced commercially. CoQ10 crystals
dissolve when they are mixed with certain solvents or if they are heated
(CoQ10’s melting point is 118°F or 48°C). CoQ10 will recrystallize upon cooling
to room temperature. This recrystallization frequently creates larger crystals
than the finely-milled starting material, which are even more difficult for the
body to assimilate. The size of CoQ10 crystals and degree of solubility of a
CoQ10 mixture will likely affect the bioavailability of CoQ10.
With all of these factors in mind, CoQsol-CF™ was created—a unique formula of
CoQ10, d-limonene, and vitamin E tocopherols. Tocopherols are added, because
they interfere with the recrystallization of CoQ10. Food grade d-limonene is
used, because it is a non-polar, organic solvent that is not water soluble. This
lipid soluble monoterpene was chosen for its solubilizing properties. CoQ10,
with its side chain of isoprenoid units, is fairly soluble in monoterpenes (also
isoprene units), including d-limonene. Research has demonstrated that the
solubilization of natural food supplements is enhanced with d-limonene
microemulsions. This essential oil component can be used with CoQ10 without
causing chemical interactions or degradation. The properties of d-limonene also
prevent the degradation of the gelatin shell, as gelatin is insoluble in most
organic solvents.
Microscopic Examination
Upon microscopic examination at 200x, CoQsol-CF™ is devoid of crystals (photo
on right), while a paste consisting of CoQ10 powder and soybean oil exhibits a
crystalline structure (photo on left). Please note that the photos have not been
retouched and were taken in our in-house laboratory. Also be aware that the
first photo displaying the crystals is NOT our CoQsol® formula!
Overall absorption can be improved by manipulating the formulation/delivery
system. A well-formulated suspension is second only to a solution in terms of
bioavailability. Suspensions are rapidly absorbed, mainly because of the large
surface area of the very small particles in the suspension. Reducing the
particle size increases the surface area of the nutrient, thus increasing the
rate and extent of g.i. absorption. The smaller the particle size the better!
Solubility and Particle Size of Coenzyme Q10 in a Soft Gelatin Formulation
Coenzyme Q10 (CoQ10) has been characterized as a poorly-soluble, crystalline
material. CoQ10 can be rendered soluble in vegetable oils or combinations of
vegetable oils and detergent compounds, however re-crystallization has been
identified as a challenge to these systems. A citrus-derived monoterpene,
d-limonene, was observed to solubilize CoQ10 and this solution was analyzed to
confirm solubility.
The solvent—a mixture of d-limonene and tocopherol—was compared with the same
solvent mixture plus the addition of CoQ10. These samples were analyzed using
visual inspection with a phase contrast microscope at magnifications of 200x,
400x, and 1000x, a dark field microscope, and polarized light microscope. No
particles were identified using any of the methods of microscopy.
The samples were also analyzed using a Particle Sizing Systems Nicomp 380 ZLS
photon correlation analyzer, a Microtrac UPA 150 Doppler Shift Photon
Correlation Analyzer, and a Malvern Zetasizer Nano instrument. Again no
particulate material could be detected in either of the samples. The lack of
particulate material indicates that CoQ10 can be fully solubilized in a solvent
comprised of d-limonene and tocopherol within the concentration limits used in
this formulation.
CoQsol-CF™ Research and Studies
We, at Soft Gel Technologies, Inc.®, wanted to determine if our CoQsol-CF™
product had good absorption and bioavailability, so a study was funded to obtain
this information in 2004.
In a pilot clinical trial involving five normal volunteers (3 men and 2
women), the peak absorption characteristics and steady state bioavailability of
CoQsol-CF™ were determined. For the control sample, volunteers were in a rested
and fasted condition—minimum eight hours. The mean control plasma level was
established to be 0.88 μg/ml.
Peak Absorption Study Results:
Starting with day 1 of the study, volunteers took 60 mg CoQsol-CF™, followed
by a breakfast consisting of orange juice or milk with a bagel or cereal, and
serial blood samples were taken at 0, 4, 6, 8, and 12 hours. Within four hours
after ingesting the CoQ10, the plasma levels for the group increased
significantly to 1.36 μg/ml. Peak plasma levels occurred at six hours (Tmax) and
the maximum plasma concentration (Cmax) was 2.28 μg/ml. Thereafter, plasma CoQ10
rapidly decreased over the next two hours to a mean level of 1.58 μg/ml.
The amount of CoQ10 absorbed at Cmax was 4,769.5 μg based on the average
plasma volume 3400 ml. When compared to the ingested dose (60,000 μg = 60 mg),
the percent of the dose absorbed at Cmax is 7.95%. This percentage makes it a
superior product in terms of absorption.
Steady State Plasma CoQ10 Bioavailability Results:
Volunteers continued taking 60 mg CoQsol-CF™ daily for 28 days. During this
time, volunteers followed their regular diet and activity, and returned to the
testing facility on days 7, 14, 21, and 28 at 6:00 a.m. in a rested and fasted
condition—minimum eight hours for collecting blood samples. The mean
plasma-level of CoQ10 were determined and data are shown in the graph. In seven
days the mean plasma CoQ10 level increased significantly to 2.39 μg/ml. At the
28th day, the mean plasma CoQ10 was 2.75 μg/ml. This means that in this steady
state study, the mean CoQ10 plasma level increased by 200% (calculated increase
was 6,458.9 μg/ml at a constant daily dose of 60 mg/day for 28 days).
The area under the plasma CoQ10 and time base curve between days 0 and 28
days (AUC) is used to determine the bioavailability of CoQsol-CF™. The AUC for
CoQsol-CF™ was 42.27μg/ml.day.
Animal Study
Soft Gel Technologies, Inc.® also funded an animal study on CoQsol-CF™ whose
main objective was to compare bioavailability and tissue distribution after
supplementation with different preparations of CoQ10, including CoQsol-CF™.
Previous studies demonstrated that CoQ10 supplementation is associated with
increased CoQ accumulation in serum and liver. The significant accumulation of
CoQ in tissues other than the liver was also observed but only when high doses
of CoQ was administered over longer periods of time. In order to establish
whether CoQsol-CF™ is superior to powder CoQ10 in terms of enhancing tissue CoQ
storage, high daily doses of both formulations are recommended.
Protocol
Young male mice were randomly assigned to 4 groups, 12 animals per group.
After acclimation, treatment groups received CoQsol-CF™, CoQsol®, or powder
CoQ10 product at the dose 300 mg/kg body weight (BW)/day, by gavage, for 10
weeks. The control group received CoQ10 vehicle (also by gavage) for the same
period of time. At the end of the study, blood was collected by heart puncture
and tissues were collected. Serum and tissue homogenates (liver, heart, skeletal
muscle, spleen, brain and lung) were analyzed for CoQ10, CoQ9, total CoQ and
reduced forms of CoQ10 and CoQ9 concentrations by HPLC (high performance liquid
chromatography).
Results
It was observed that different preparations lead to accumulation of CoQ in
different organs. The graphs depicted below illustrate that various CoQ10
delivery systems accumulate in different tissue types. CoQsol-CF™ demonstrated
enhanced accumulation in blood serum, heart, and liver tissue, all of which are
key storage and use locations for CoQ. Supplementation with our original CoQsol®
formula resulted in the accumulation of total CoQ in mitochondria isolated from
heart, brain and spleen. Even the CoQ10 powder showed enhanced uptake in muscle
and lung tissue. The results of the present study suggest that different
preparations are metabolized in different ways leading to the differences
observed in tissue accumulation.
Click on image for full size
Limitations of Animal Study
The mouse is a challenging model for CoQ10 research, because rodents’ primary
storage form of CoQ is CoQ9. Lipid metabolism differs from humans in that the
major source of cholesterol in rodents is from HDL (85-90%), whereas humans
obtain cholesterol from LDL. In addition, high serum levels of CoQ in mice may
significantly reduce blood pressure, thereby causing a negative response.
Despite these limitations, the mouse model provided useful insight for future
work.
Future Clinical Study
Design
A randomized, multi-center, parallel study comparing the bioavailabilities of
two coenzyme Q10 formulations (CoQsol-CF™ and CoQ10 powder in hard shell
capsules) in 30 healthy, human subjects has been initiated. Steady state and
acute dose bioavailability in plasma and tissues will be investigated.
Antioxidant properties of the two coenzyme Q10 preparations will also be
compared. The values studied will include: total antioxidant status, total
plasma glutathione, and isoprostane lipid peroxide levels. Functional measures
of cardiovascular health including homocysteine and CRP levels will also be
measured. In addition, safety data will be gathered.
About the Company
Soft Gel Technologies,
Inc.® (SGTI®) is a leading contract manufacturer providing specialty soft
gelatin encapsulation that exceeds the highest standards of quality, purity, and
performance to the Natural Products industry. What rivals our drive to excel in
supplying the finest soft gels, is our desire to provide our customers with the
most comprehensive service possible. SGTI®’s leading product is a patented,
highly-bioavailable CoQ10 soft gel marketed as CoQsol®. Other key products
include GlucoTrim®, a banaba leaf extract for blood glucose management, and
Injuv®, a low molecular weight hyaluronic acid for cosmeceutical and joint
health applications. Soft Gel Technologies,
Inc.® is a privately-held company based in Los Angeles, CA.
Course Post Test
We hope you enjoyed reading the course
materials about CoQsol-CF, now it's time to take the post test and get
your certificate of completion from nutrilearn and Soft Gel
Technologies, Inc.. There is
no cost associated with taking the course post test and
downloading your certificate.
First you will need to add the course to your shopping cart.
Click
here to add the course to the shopping cart.
Next you will need to complete the checkout process from the
nutrilearn store. If you already have an existing nutrilearn
account use your credentials on the "check out" screen. If you
are new to the nutrilearn site, you will need to click on the "sign
up" button and create your profile.
Complete the check out process, by submitting your order.
Once you have submitted your order, click on the link to return
to the nutrilearn web site at the top of the page.
Click on the "sign in" link (key icon) and log in with your
credentials in the upper right corner of the nutrilearn home page.
Once you are logged in to the system, you will see a 'courses'
link in the upper right corner of the page, click on the 'courses'
link.
To take the post test, click on the Test link next to the
course.
If you already have the CoQsol-CF course in your nutrilearn.com
profile, you can click
here
to take the post test.
References
Bargossi AM et al. Exogenous CoQ10 supplementation prevents plasma ubiquinone
reduction induced by HMG-CoA reductase inhibitors. Mol Aspects Med 1994;
15:S187.
Folkers K. Relevance of the biosynthesis of coenzyme Q10 and of the four
bases of DNA as a rationale for the molecular causes of cancer and a therapy.
Biochem Biophys Res Commun 1996;224:358-61.
Folkers K et al. Activities of vitamin Q10 in animal models and a serious
deficiency in patients with cancer. Biochem Biophys Res Commun 1997;234:296-9.
Folkers K et al. Two successful double-blind trials with coenzyme Q10
(vitamin Q10) on muscular dystrophies and neurogenic atrophies. Biochim Biophys
Acta 1995;1271:281-6.
Greenberg S et al. Co-enzyme Q10: a new drug for cardiovascular disease. J
Clin Pharmacol 1990; 30:596-608.
Hofman-Bang C et. al. Coenzyme Q10 as an adjunctive in the treatment of
chronic congestive heart failure. The Q10 Study Group. J Card Fail 1995;1:101-7.
Hofman-Bang C et al. Coenzyme Q10 as an adjunctive treatment of congestive
heart failure. J Am Coll Cardiol. 1992;19:216A.
Kaji I et al. Inhibition by d-Limonene of experimental hepatocarcinogenesis
in sprague-dawley rats does not involve P21RAS plasma membrane association. Int
J Cancer 2001; 93:441.
Koroshetz WJ et al. Energy metabolism defects in Huntington's disease and
effects of coenzyme Q10. Ann Neurol 1997;41:160-5.
Langsjoen PH et al. Treatment of hypertrophic cardiomyopathy with coenzyme
Q10. Mol Aspects Med 1997;18:S145-51.
Langsjoen H et al. Usefulness of coenzyme Q10 in clinical cardiology: a
long-term study. Mol Aspects Med. 1994;15(suppl):S165–S175.
Lu, M. et al.,“Muscle Relaxing Activity of Hyssopus Officinalis Essential Oil
on Isolated Intestinal Preparations,”Planta.Med. 68 (3), 213–216 (2002).
Matthews RT et al. Coenzyme Q10 administration increases brain mitochondria
concentrations and exerts neuro-protective effects. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 1998;
95:8892.
Mortensen SA et al. Dose-related decrease of serum coenzyme Q10 during
treatment with HMG-CoA reductase inhibitors. Mol Aspects Med 1997; 18:S137-44.
Palamakula, A., et. al., “Preparation and In Vitro Characterization of Self-Nanoemulsified
Drug Delivery Systems of Coenzyme Q10 Using Chiral Essential Oil Components,”
Pharmaceutical Technology. 74–88 (2004).
Trease, GE et al., Pharmacognosy, 13th. edition, Balliere Tindall, 1989
Willard, Terry, The Textbook of Advanced Herbology, Wild Rose Publications,
1992.
Yamagami T et al. Bioenergetics in clinical medicine. Studies on coenzyme Q10
and essential hypertension. Res Commun Chem Pathol Pharmacol 1975; 11:273.