Keeping Chronic Inflammation in Check
Cooling immune system wildfires for longevity
by Steve Myers
Underlying the body’s healing response is a
process by which tissues inflame. Chronic inflammation, if left unchecked, can
devastate the body’s tissues, especially in the vascular and nervous systems.
Numerous natural products help control the inflammation switch, keeping many
maladies at bay.
Blame it on a rush of blood—specifically a rush of immune cells, including
proteins and various white blood cells, which flood “injured” tissues,
guarding against infection and promoting healing. This is actually a good thing,
when the inflammation switch is turned on and off as the injury or infection
warrants.
The immune-inflammation response involves numerous cells and chemicals. Mast
cells release histamine and cytokines, which signal an alarm. Small vessels
release additional immune cells, while macrophages continue their front-line
defense against pathogens employing chemicals such as nitric oxide (NO).
Neutrophils engulf and destroy bacteria and damaged tissue, and reinforcements
arrive as lymphocytes. Platelets initiate clotting and fibrin, and other
substances envelope the wound. Other immune chemicals released during
inflammation include nuclear factor kappa-B (NFkappaB), tumor necrosis factor
alpha (TNFa) and various interleukin (IL).
As with other defense mechanisms, the immune system has a complex network of
pathways through which it starts and stops inflammation, as needed. Leukotrienes
and prostaglandins are inflammation mediators derived from arachidonic acid (AA)
via metabolism in distinct enzymatic pathways. Leukotrienes are produced via the
5-lipoxygenase (5-LOX) pathway, while prostaglandins and thromboxanes are born
from the cyclooxygenase pathway (COX). COX-1 is involved in pain and clotting;
COX-2 is also involved in pain, but its mechanism is related to inflammation.
This is why many pharmaceuticals were designed to disrupt the COX-2 pathway.
Unfortunately, COX-2 inhibitors pose danger to the cardiovascular system via
production of vasoconstrictive thromboxanes. COX-1 produces pro-thromboxane
compounds—useful in promoting clotting—while COX-2 compounds (prostacyclin)
keep thromboxane in check, helping to prevent hypertension and atherothrombosis.
By inhibiting COX-2, pharmaceuticals like Vioxx and Celebrex consistently throw
off the balance of thromboxane’s waxing and waning. While inhibiting COX-2
pro-inflammatory activity, the drugs also put patients at a higher risk of
atherothrombosis and cardiac trouble after even a short period of medication.
For a long time, many people self-treated inflammation and pain using
non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs), which act along the COX
pathways. “NSAIDs are linked to further joint destruction and also both kidney
damage and increased risk of gastric bleeding,” said Chris Meletis, N.D.,
director of science and research with Trace Minerals Research.
Joelle Lynchuk, new product development specialist with Bioriginal Food &
Science Corp., added, “With NSAIDs, for example, gastrointestinal
complications have been identified in some people.”
Similar to AA’s activity, EFAs produce eicosanoids (signaling compounds)
via various LOX and COX enzymes. The omega-3 chain starts with linolenic acid
(LNA), which competes with the omega-6 alpha linoleic acid (ALA) for a certain
desaturase enzyme for further metabolism. Downstream, LNA converts to
eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA) and docosahexaenoic acid (DHA), which tend to
generate anti-inflammatory eicosanoids; on the other hand, ALA converts to gamma
linoleic acid (GLA) and then primarily AA, which produces eicosanoids that tend
to act in a pro-inflammatory manner.
Eicosanoids
control functions such as inflammation and immune response, in addition to
serving as messengers for the nervous system. Eicosanoids produced by EPA, DHA
and AA include various prostaglandins, prostacyclins, leukotrienes and
thromboxanes.
Ingredients rich in LNA, such as flaxseed, can help by supplying raw
materials to produce the longer-chain EPA and DHA and the resulting
anti-inflammatory eicosanoids; but, much attention has turned to fish oil, which
inherently supplies rich amounts of EPA and DHA.
In fact, EPA and DHA have proven themselves worthy adversaries of AA-derived
pro-inflammatory eicosanoids.1 EPA and even GLA-derived DGLA compete
with AA for LOX and COX enzymes, often resulting in decreased AA eicosanoids.
Specifically, EPA inhibits prostaglandin-2 (PG2) and thromboxane.2
Douglas MacKay, N.D., research advisor to Nordic Naturals, explained PGE3
is derived from EPA, and higher levels of PGE3 reduce sensitivity to pain, relax
blood vessels, increase blood flow, and support the body’s natural
anti-inflammatory response. “It is important to remember that both PGE2 and
PGE3 are necessary,” he noted. “It is the relative amounts of these
competing messenger molecules that will either contribute to, or mitigate,
chronic pain and inflammatory syndromes.”
EPA also lowers series-4 leukotrienes from AA, instead raising less active
series-5 leukotrienes.3 For its part, DHA does not produce active
eicosanoids, but has been shown to decrease AA’s production of inflammatory
prostanoids.4 Further, GLA-derived DGLA produces PGE-1 to counteract AA’s
PGE2, while EPA offers leukotriene B-5 (LTB5) to counter AA’s LTB4,
a more inflammatory compound.5 EPA- and DHA-rich fish oil has
demonstrated similar effects on inflammatory compounds, such as IL-6, C-reactive
protein (CRP), TNFa and transforming growth factor beta (TGF-beta).6,7,8
Such mechanisms by fish oil EFAs have been investigated relative to various
inflammatory health problems affecting the skin, eyes, heart and joints. In
fact, researchers have credited fish oil supplementation with producing
increased amounts of anti-inflammatory cytokines, such as IL-10, as well as
regulating gene expression, which suggests the supplement can address dermatitis
concerns.9
Recently, researchers reported DHA, the principal EFA in the retina, inhibits
cytokine-induced adhesion molecule expression in human retinal cells affected by
diabetic retinopathy.10 In subsequent work, these Michigan State
University researchers found DHA incorporated into retinal caveolae/lipid
rafts—discrete regions within the plasma membrane that coordinate and regulate
a variety of signaling processes—affects cholesterol levels and, in turn,
cytokine-induced signaling.11
In other areas of eye inflammation, higher omega-3 intake was found to
improve age-related macular degeneration (AMD) by increasing DHA levels in rod
outer segment membranes, while reducing pro-inflammatory omega-6 activity.12
University of Michigan researchers linked fish oils to a possible decrease in
risk of AMD.13
One of the places inflammation has reared its ugly head of late has been in
cardiovascular disease (CVD).
“Epidemiological studies have demonstrated increased CVD risk in
individuals with elevated serum levels of cytokines such as IL-6 and TNFa; cell
adhesion molecules such as intercellular adhesion molecule-1 and P-selectin; and
acute-phase proteins such as CRP, fibrinogen and serum amyloid, as well as uric
acid and homocysteine,” reported Vladimir Badmaev, Ph.D., vice president of
scientific and medical affairs with Sabinsa Corp. “Of the listed serum
markers, high-sensitivity CRP measurement has the most potential for clinical
use because high levels of hsCRP are associated with a two-fold to threefold
increase in the prevalence of myocardial infarction, stroke and peripheral
vascular disease, and it predicts incident cardiovascular events in those with
and without preexisting CVD.”
Omega-3s and fish oil have been extensively studied for actions in cases of
fatal arrhythmias and vascular dysfunction. Italian scientists noted omega-3s
have been shown to decrease activation of adhesion molecules and inflammatory
cytokines involved in endothelial function and inflammation; they added this
gene regulation is related to decreased activation of NFkappaB transcription
factors, further suggesting the high number of double bonds in the long chain
EFAs may be key to the benefit.14 They also pointed to the ability of
omega-3s to reduce COX-2 gene expression, which affects plaque angiogenesis and
rupture.
According to Lynchuk, omega-3 eicosanoids are particularly adept at vascular
improvements. “GLA is known to produce prostaglandins series 1, while EPA
produces prostaglandins series 3,” she said. “These particular prostaglandin
types are known to have anti-inflammatory effects in the body and aid in the
dilation of blood vessels as well as the dis-aggregation of platelets.”
Jan Breslow, M.D., head of the Laboratory of Biochemical Genetics and
Metabolism at Rockefeller University, New York, reported the evidence from
randomized control trials (RCTs) suggests the benefits of EPA and DHA in heart
health are due to suppression of fatal arrhythmias, rather than stabilization of
atherosclerotic plaques.15 British scientists from City Hospital
Birmingham University of Medicine noted atrial biopsies from patients with
arrhythmia have confirmed the presence of inflammation, and indicated fish oil
might help by modulating inflammatory pathways.16
Omega-3s and fish oil have also proven useful in various autoimmune
conditions, which are based in inflammation. Fish oil’s modulation of
inflammatory compounds provides positive results against juvenile diabetes and
psoriasis (defined by the existence of plaques)—both of which feature altered
eicosanoid metabolism—as well as by increased AA and its pro-inflammatory
metabolites.17,18 And, fish oil supplementation helped control
pro-inflammatory prostaglandins, cytokines and chemokines in rheumatoid
arthritis (RA) patients.19 Crohn’s and lupus patients have also
benefited from EPA and DHA trials, which have resulted in mediation of
inflammatory cytokines.20,21
Omega-3 management of eicosanoids is also a benefit for people with cancer,
especially as an adjunctive to conventional cancer treatment. Texas A&M
researchers studied the connection between chronic inflammation and colorectal
cancer, finding fish oil EFAs directly suppress Th1 cell development, favorably
altering the balance between Th1 and Th2 cells.22
Even GLA, with its confusing mechanisms of action in the COX/LOX
pathways—it can covert to but also competes with/inhibits AA—has
demonstrated benefits to inflammatory diseases, especially in joint health
issues. In vivo and in vitro examination of GLA in RA cells resulted in
suppressed pro-inflammatory IL-1 and TNFa, suggesting GLA suppresses synovitis
in RA patients.23 GLA is abundant in evening primrose oil and borage
oil, both of which have demonstrated activities against inflammatory
prostaglandins and leukotrienes, as well as reduction of AA oxygenation
byproducts.24,25 A 2004 trial looked at evening primrose oil, as well
as virgin olive oil (omega-9 EFA) and fish oil, relative to stimulating
production of inflammatory mediators by leukocytes.26 All three EFA
oils reduced pesky inflammatory PGE2.
Inflammation can be a silent marauder in health issues such as heart disease
and cancer, but many people with chronic joint pain hear inflammation’s roar.
When the immune system thinks cartilage and other joint tissues are foreign or
infected, it attacks with the full heat of its inflammatory arsenal, causing
heat, pain and pressure. RA is the most common manifestation of this joint
misfortune.
The king of joint health supplements, glucosamine alone has eased the pain of
RA by way of inhibiting inflammatory compounds and their activities, including
iNOS expression.27,28,29 In a common tandem, glucosamine and
chondroitin have decreased inflammation, IL-1 and MMP-9 to a greater degree than
chondroitin alone.30
The word arthritis means joint inflammation, and all forms of the disease end
up involving some degree of swelling and pain in the joint. Inflammation may not
be the chief culprit in osteoarthritis (OA), but European researchers comparing
synovial tissue in early- and late-stage OA patients recently reported increased
mononuclear cell infiltration and over-expression of mediators of inflammation
were seen in early OA, compared to late OA.31
Synovial inflammation can be addressed with hyaluronic acid (HA), a primary
component of the synovial fluid lubricant found between bones. While injected HA
is more studied for decreasing synovial levels of certain inflammatory factors,
including VCAM-1 and ICAM-1,32 oral HA supplementation has slowly
begun to generate similar results on inflammatory markers.33
Inflammation in OA appears to be mediated by leukocyte and neutrophil (white
blood cell) activities. Combating this, milk protein concentrate (as Microlactin™,
from Humanetics Corp.) has been shown to suppress vascular neutrophil activity,
while increasing the absolute serum neutrophil count.34 Based on this
mechanism, scientists have suggested milk-based supplements can alleviate pain,
swelling and dysfunction associated with OA.35
Cetylated fatty acid esters also improve chronic OA symptoms, including
swelling. Experts hypothesize this family of fatty acid esters (as Celadrin®,
available from Pacific Rainbow) possibly modulates COX-1 and COX-2 activity, and
may even inhibit LOX. Studies suggest Celadrin topical cream can reduce pain and
joint function in people with OA,36 in addition to improving knee
function.37
Lorna Vanderhaeghe, medical journalist and author of Get a Grip on
Arthritis and Other Inflammatory Disorders, said Celadrin works similar to,
but much more dramatically than, EPA and DHA. “The esterified fatty acids
present in Celadrin have pronounced anti-inflammatory effects, such as the
inhibition of inflammation in endothelial cells and decreasing the
pro-inflammatory effects of other fatty acids like arachidonic acid,” she
explained.
Vanderhaeghe noted most people only think about inflammation in regard to
arthritis, yet inflammation can be a very serious problem in other parts of the
body and should be addressed long before symptoms become apparent.
The botanical joint aid Boswellia serrata works along the LOX pathway
to offer anti-inflammatory benefits to people suffering from not only arthritis,
but also other inflammatory ailments such as Crohn’s, asthma and colitis.38,39
A study on boswellia (as WOKVEL, from Verdure Sciences) and the
anti-inflammatory drug valdecoxib in arthritis patients found improved knee and
joint function from a combination of the two treatments.40 Results
from the six-month, randomized, prospective, comparative study showed an overall
decrease in WOMAC (Western Ontario and McMaster University Osteoarthritis Index)
scores from both treatments; but, after treatments ceased, the benefit was far
more sustained in the boswellia group, as the drug group scores elevated back to
baseline levels. The researchers reported boswellic acid may act on the
functional cellular processes involved in the inflammatory response.
A 2006 study also supported boswellia’s anti-inflammatory actions in
arthritis, as in vivo and in vitro experiments on microvascular endothelial
cells revealed pretreatment with 5-Loxin® (from P.L. Thomas and Laila
Nutraceuticals) inhibited TNFa expression and various matrix metalloproteinases
(MMPs), which can degrade collagen and elastin.41 Genetic research
has shown 113 of the 522 genes induced by TNFa are sensitive to boswellia (as
5-Loxin), as researchers reported boswellia inhibited TNFa-induced expression of
VCAM-1 and ICAM-1 genes, which recruit inflammatory chemicals to the inflamed
area.42
Turmeric has also proven itself particularly adept at curtailing LOX and
COX-2, as well as the inflammatory activities of NFkappaB, IL-12 and iNOS.43,44,45
Badmaev explained the yellow pigment from turmeric is essentially a mixture
of three related compounds—curcumin, demethoxycurcumin and
bisdemethoxycurcumin—collectively termed as curcuminoids, which are
well-researched antioxidant and anti-inflammatory agents. “The curcuminoids
inhibit the COX-2 enzyme, with curcumin being the strongest inhibitor; [they]
are also active against the COX-1 enzyme, with demethoxycurcumin showing the
highest activity against COX-1,” he noted. “All curcumins have demonstrated
greater inhibition of COX-2 rather than COX-1 enzyme, with no gastrointestinal
irritation and discomfort—a side effect typical of the NSAID class of
drugs.”
In recent research, curcumin has been effective in quelling inflammation and
oxidative damage in cases ranging from Alzheimer’s disease to cancer.46,47
Badmaev added, “Curcumin inhibits the ‘master switch’ of the inflammatory
process, NFkappaB, which in turn inhibits COX-2 and -1, as well as several
cancer promoting compounds such as TNFa and inflammation promoting interleukins,
e.g. IL-1b and IL-8.”
This mechanism of action is also a key to curcumin’s benefits to chronic
colitis patients.48 It also explains turmeric’s results against experimental
arthritis, inhibiting joint inflammation and periarticular joint destruction.49
Herbs and spices continue to impact inflammation research. Ginger has
demonstrated anti-inflammatory properties useful in various conditions.
According to Badmaev, the ginger root constituents gingerols and metabolites
shogaols are keys to the anti-inflammatory action, inhibiting prostaglandins and
leukotrienes. The herb also contains vanillyl ketones, which have been shown to
help modulate TNFa production.50 In fact, an osteoarthritis (OA)
study reported ginger inhibited production of TNFa and COX-2 expression, thereby
stifling NFkappaB induction.51
Another herb found to modulate COX enzymes is French maritime pine bark
extract, which curbed COX-1 and -2 in human serum research.52 More
specifically, the extract influences cell adhesion molecule (CAM) expression in
inflammatory conditions. University of California, Berkeley, scientists
pretreated human keratinocyte cell lines with pine bark (as Pycnogenol®, from
Natural Health Science) and found the extract significantly inhibited
IFN-gamma-induced expression of ICAM-1 expression in those cells.53
They concluded this mechanism has potential to help people with inflammatory
skin disorders. Other scientists have found Pycnogenol is a good therapy for
inflammatory components of systemic lupus and asthma.54,55
Antioxidants have also made their mark against inflammation. Astaxanthin, a
carotenoid commonly sourced from microalgae, has inhibited inflammatory
compounds such as NFkappaB, TNFa, NO, PGE2 and IL-1b in a mouse model.56
Research has suggested a possible interaction of astaxanthin and the 5-LOX
enzyme as key to its benefits in chronic inflammation, such as in CVD, asthma
and cancer.57 A Japanese animal study concluded the anti-inflammatory
effect of 100 mg/kg astaxanthin was as strong as that of 10 mg/kg prednisolone,
a corticosteroidal anti-inflammatory drug.58 The researchers noted
astaxanthin decreased production of NO, PGE2 and TNFa, in addition to reducing
iNOS activity. Astaxanthin has also reduced gastric inflammation associated with
H. pylori infection, shifting T-lymphocyte response from pro-inflammatory to
homeostasis.59
Other carotenoids have delivered similar inflammation relief. Lutein, found
in high concentration in the retina, has improved inflammation in the eye,
helping in AMD and various retinopathies.60 Lutein inhibits NO
synthase (NOS) and COX-2 expression in challenged retinas in a dose-dependent
fashion.61 While effective and well-explored for eye health,
lutein’s actions also help in reducing skin inflammation, especially relative
to sun exposure and aging, by decreasing the expression of iNOS at the mRNA and
protein levels.63,64
Eating Away at Inflammation
The gut is particularly susceptible to inflammation, rearing its ugly head as
inflammatory bowel diseases (IBDs), including Crohn’s and colitis. Probiotics
are the frontline natural defense against IBDs, as they inhibit the expression
of inflammatory cytokines in the gut.66 Probiotic supplementation is
all about the bacteria strain, as many studies have focused on specific
probiotic varieties. Lactobacillus farciminis has been shown to help
maintain intestinal integrity and modulate inflammatory response in rats with
colitis.67Lactobacillus GG has proven effective at managing
expression of immune and inflammation genes, including TGF-beta, TNFa,
cytokines, NOS and ICAM, in the small bowel mucosa of male IBD patients.68
And L. paracasei was found to modulate mucosal inflammation in UC rats by
reducing colonic cytokines.69 In another study, a combination of
lactobacilli and bifido taken by patients prior to pouchitis surgery decreased
symptoms and post-operative endoscopic inflammation.70
Similarly, digestive enzymes, proteolytic enzymes (catalyze
proteins)—including papain, bromelain, pancreatin, trypsin and serrata
peptidase—exert systemic effects on inflammation. Individually, the pineapple
proteinase bromelain has demonstrated potent proteolytic activity in the GI
tract, and scientists report bromelain supplementation may affect leukocyte
migration and cytokine production.71 In other research, bromelain
supplementation decreased PGE2 and substance P concentrations in rats,72
and deceased colonic inflammation in ulcerative colitis patients.73
The anti-inflammatory benefits of enzymes are not limited to the GI tract,
however, as studies also indicated benefits to arthritis sufferers,74,75
and significant inroads to relief from inflammation in CVD.76
Justin Marsh, president and CEO of Arthur Andrew Medical, explained
circulatory disease is directly related to the purity of the blood and our
body’s ability to cleanse it. He noted, “Circulatory or blood cleansing is
one of the many features of systemic enzyme supplementation.”
Marsh explained systemic enzymes, specifically nattokinase and serrapeptase
in clinical strength, are both proteolytic (protein digesting) and thrombolitc
(blood clot digesting). When introduced to the bloodstream, these enzymes
quickly digest protein-based substances such as undigested food particles,
arterial plaque, scar tissue and certain prostaglandins. An advantage of these
natural anti-inflammatory products is the specific electrical charge of these
enzymes prevents them from digesting living tissue, according to Marsh.
“Papain and bromelain reduce inflammations by digesting certain inflammatory
prostaglandins,” he noted. “These enzymes only activate at just above normal
body temperature, specifically at the same temperature as inflammation, since
this is always higher than the rest of the body.”
To view the references for this story, click
here.
To take the exam for this course, please make sure you have the course in your
nutrilearn.com profile. If you need to add the course to your profile
click here
and complete the checkout process.
If you already have the course in your profile and are ready to take the test,
click here
or visit your profile once you are logged in to the nutrilearn system. Note: To access the
available courses in your profile, click on the "courses" link at
the top of the page once you are logged in.